Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Great Fluoride Debate - Canadian Paper!

June 5, 2012 >  Letter to the Editor of "Lethbridge Herald" >

Fluoridation was a mistake that needs to be corrected

http://www.lethbridgeherald.com/letters-to-the-editor/fluoridation-was-a-mistake-that-needs-to-be-corrected-6512.html#comments

The writer was adding their 2 cents worth to the debate, questioning the need for the fluoride poison being in their drinking water when it also gets on their garden vegetables.  The writer quoted a study about it causing  hypothyroidism.

Comments below it started out mocking the writer.  I began quoting scientific studies to them, including one that backed up what the writer had mentioned with hypothyroidism, and the attack turned on me, BUT they began to provide studies of their own to back up their statements, so now we're in a real "debate" - Come join the fun! :-)))

Monday, June 4, 2012

TV Debate on Fluoride!! (in Australia)

Student's political debate TV pilot
4th June 2012
http://www.northernstar.com.au/story/2012/06/04/student-launch-political-debate-tv-pilot/
(picture of Alex Lewers, and article has more details)

Fluoride hits TV screens
4th June 2012
http://www.northernstar.com.au/story/2012/06/04/fluoride-hits-tv-screens-lismore-health/

"GRAB your popcorn, public forum lovers - four Northern Rivers mayors will soon be debating the merits of water fluoridation in a public Q&A style television pilot at Southern Cross University.


"Project founder Alex Lewers says the pilot aims to invigorate politics with a depth and substance lacking in the age of soundbites and slogans.

"It's about getting leaders to engage in less shouting and spin, and more actual debate," said the SCU Bachelor of Media Arts honours student.

"He wants to rekindle the media's traditional function as a political watchdog.

"Research shows the media doesn't spend enough time looking at issues."

"As a result, Australians are voting for representatives whose views aren't always clear to voters in their electorates."

"Water fluoridation remains a hot issue in the Northern Rivers despite tenacious campaigner Al Oshlack's recently overturned appeal to stop Rous Water introducing fluoride to local drinking water.

"Only Byron Shire Council remains opposed to fluoridation.

"Each mayor will have three minutes to outline their stance on the contentious issue before questions from the live studio audience."

Q&A DETAILS

The Fourth Estate: A TV pilot debate

Where: SCU Lismore's ONE29 studio.

When: June 25, 5-7pm

Subject: 'Is water fluoridation the best method of preventing oral health problems in the Northern Rivers?'

To book: Contact Alex Lewers at fourth.estate2012@gmail.com, giving your name, position on the issue (for, against, uncommitted), age and local government area (Ballina, Lismore, etc).

New ADA study confirms danger of fluoride


EconomicPolicyJournal.com




http://www.economicpolicyjournal.com/2012/06/ada-study-confirms-dangers-of.html

Sunday, June 3, 2012

ADA Study Confirms Dangers of Fluoridated Water

A new study published in the Journal of the American Dental Association confirms fluoride as a toxic substance that actually destroys teeth, particularly those of developing young children and babies.

Natural News reports:
When people are exposed to excessive levels of fluoride through sources like drinking water, foods and beverages and even swallowed toothpaste, it often results in a condition known as dental fluorosis. The internal uptake of fluoride into teeth over time causes their enamel to become mottled and discolored, the end result being damaged teeth that have essentially rotted from the inside out.

Dr. Steven Levy, D.D.S., and his team found during their study that "fluoride intakes during each of the first four years (of a child's life) were individually significantly related to fluorosis on maxillary central incisors, with the first year more important." They went on to warn that "infant formulas reconstituted with higher fluoride water can provide 100 to 200 times more fluoride than breast milk, or cow's milk."

Of course, if you would have been reading Murray Rothbard, you would have known about the fluoride scam decades ago. He was warning us all in 1993!

And Rothbard nailed what was behind the push to put fluoride in the water.
There is an instructive lesson in this little saga, a lesson how and why the Welfare State came to America. It came as an alliance of three major forces: ideological social democrats, ambitious technocratic bureaucrats, and Big Businessmen seeking privileges from the State. In the fluoridation saga, we might call the whole process "ALCOA-socialism." The Welfare State redounds to the welfare not of most of society but of these particular venal and exploitative groups.

(htIrisMack)

Friday, June 1, 2012

More Cities Looking @ Fluoridation

FOX-6 News Video:  News conferences held to debate safety of water fluoridation (in Milwaukee)
May 31, 2012:   Milwaukee Alderman Jim Bohl is adamant that fluoridation in Milwaukee’s drinking water is a bad thing. Bohl held a news conference Thursday at Milwaukee’s City Hall with experts, to champion his point...Those in favor of fluoridation also held a news conference Thursday at City Hall...Bohl introduced his resolution to end fluoridation and create an oral health program for medically-underserved children, with the $540,000 the city would have spent on fluoridation...The debate resumed at the meeting over what’s best for Milwaukee’s water system, and for the 15 other communities that utilize it..."
May 22, 2012:  Video of Sacramento Budget Hearing about Fluoridation by Residents
May 30, 2012:  New campaigns to focus on Wichita water fluoridation
"Educational campaigns on fluoridiation start this week from the Kansas Health Foundation and the group Wichitans for Healthy Teeth. The health foundation says Wichita is the fourth largest city in the country without fluoridated water...The foundation's campaign will include TV and radio ads, billboards and social media outreach. Coen (CEO of Kansas Health Foundation) says its focus will be for people to understand that fluoride is a safe and natural way to prevent tooth decay..."We have communities in Kansas that actually do have naturally fluoridated water, communities like Dodge City, Scott City and Colby," said Coen. "It is a natural element that occurs in water.'" (Sidebar Note by Ken:  Coen stated that Wichita has fluoride in its water, "naturally," but it's only .33 ppm, and they want to add more fluoride to it....so Wichita has a natural mineral fluorine, but now they want to add a hazardous waste by-product to it and tell the folks it's "a safe and natural way to prevent tooth decay."--does that make any logical sense??)
May 31, 2012:  Fluoridation overdue  (in Wichita Kansas)
"Local voters rejected water fluoridation in 1964 and 1978, and elected officials variously have treated it with disdain or indifference ever since – as if they could ignore it and make it go away.
"This time the advocates themselves are too formidable to ignore: the Kansas Health Foundation, which is launching a website (www.FluorideForUs.com) and ad campaign, and a new group dubbed Wichitans for Healthy Teeth (wichitansforhealthyteeth.org) that has the Wichita District Dental Society, the Medical Society of Sedgwick County and a total of 368 local dentists, physicians and other medical professionals behind it. The latter group is seeking grant money to offset the modest infrastructure costs of water fluoridation for Wichita – and to counter arguments that it would be too costly..."
May 31, 2012:  "The Irish Times - (New) Report prompts councils to call for public review of water fluoridation (in Ireland)
"...360-page report, (locally, a) Bandon-based environmental auditor Declan Waugh found that babies fed with formula mixed with fluoridated water were at particular risk. “No child under the age of three should be exposed to fluoride,” he said. “They don’t even have teeth."  *****SIDEBAR NOTE added by KEN:  "IrishTimes.com," June 2, 2012 - posted "Corrections & Clarifications" as saying that Declan Waugh was "wrongly quoted" when reporting that he'd said, "They don't even have teeth."  I guess that means he never said that part of it, since they don't give any other quote from him to replace it with.  Here's their link to the correction:
http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/opinion/2012/0602/1224317133462.html 

"The Risk Assessment of Water Fluoridation report says fluoride is a known risk factor in a series of health problems particularly prevalent in Ireland, including neurological and cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, osteoporosis and skeletal muscular disorders.

"Ireland is the only EU member state with a legislative policy to add fluoride to the water supply. “The incidence of these diseases in Ireland is far above the global average,” Mr Waugh added.

“Ireland has twice the global average of osteoporosis, one of the highest levels in the world of childhood epilepsy and certain type of cancers associated with the digestive tract, including cancer of the liver, kidney, stomach and intestinal cancer.”

"Bandon and Kinsale town councils have agreed to ask the Minister for Health to review water fluoridation immediately.

"Minister for the Environment Phil Hogan said last November that he “trusted the processes in place.'"


Read more here: http://www.kansas.com/2012/05/31/2354485/fluoridation-overdue.html#storylink=cpy




Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Salina, Kansas newest city to fight fluoride

Group Urges Salina To Stop Adding Fluoride To Water

http://www.ksallink.com/?cmd=displaystory&story_id=22172&format=html

You Gotta Read the"white paper" that "proves" the case for fluoride!!

http://www.scienceinmedicine.org/policy/papers/AntiFluoridationist.pdf

At the very beginning they tell the reader that fluoride opponents totally misrepresent the valid research of the National Research Council's (NRC) 2006 study  by stating that the study was a focus on those living in the US cities who had "natural" fluoride levels that were double or triple the levels in the managed fluoridated cities.  They end it by reminding us that, after all, "As the NRC itself stated, 'it is important to note that the safety and effectiveness of the practice of water fluoridation was outside the scope of this report and is not evaluated.'”


First, they cite NYSCOF with quoting a case in 2009 and another case in 2010 that's supposed to totally discredit them for misrepresentation of some women who died of fluoride overdose but left out that one drank brick tea that automatically has high levels of fluoride in it and brushed her teeth with fluoridated toothpaste every two hours, and the other woman allegedly ate a tube of toothpaste every other day, so both got higher doses of fluoride then what is in the water, and it's not "fair" to compare them to the managed water levels.

Second, they discredit a Canadian website regarding Europe's ban on fluoride, saying it's a spin, and then mentions that the Canadian website "leaves out" that Europe has fluoridated table salt and fluoridated milk.

Third, they claim the fluoride opponents misquote the HHS's Assistant Secretary of Health, Dr. Howard Koh, when he gave the infant fluoride warning.  The two dentist's "white paper" claims that,  "This HHS message suggests another option for parents who may be concerned about fluorosis, but it is a far cry from telling parents to avoid fluoridated water."

Fourth, they attack Fluoride Action Network website with using scare stories that are about fluoride effects in India that has huge amounts of it from pollution and natural ground water that's "15 times higher" than what we have in the United States.  They attack the NYSCOF website again by quoting a Chinese study with fluoride causing bone fractures, stating that the Chinese use brick tea that has high levels of natural fluoride that's between "3 and 10 times higher" than in the US's fluoridated drinking water.

Fifth, they quote the opponents of fluoride who quote the study done in Cuba, where the cavities went down when fluoride was removed in 1990, but say the opponents neglect to include that fluoridated mouth wash was started in their school system that same year.  (Wait, hold on! If Cuba had fluoridated water already when they stopped in 1990, then how did the cavities go down just from using fluoridated mouth rinse at school??  Logically speaking, wouldn't the cavity rate have been down already from their fluoridated water??)

Sixth, they discredit all fluoride opponents who quote any medical authorities by stating, "...several of these quotes are more than 40 years old and, therefore, are not based on the latest research."  They give the example of fluoride opponents quoting a former AMA president from 1930's before fluoridation was even in practice as their "proof" of quoting old research.

Seventh, they quote headlines from fluoride opponents who ask if it's "possible" that fluoride could cause such-n-such disease, without any scientific data to back up the scare tactic, such as "Could Fluoride Cause Fibromyalgia?" as one example.

Eighth, one by one, they attack and try to discredit a list of persons who have ever been vocal against fluoride!  Quackwatch.com and other "various" resources reveal what's "wrong" with these anti-fluoride people:  Mike Adams (he called fluoride "rat poison," and he's also against vaccinations), Dr. Mercola (the FDA has sent him warning letters to stop promoting alternative health care), Dr. Yiamouyiannis, (a chemist who falsely claimed that HIV did not cause AIDS, was close friends with Dr. Paul Connett, and besides, he died at age 58 from rectal cancer because he refused conventional treatment, and "Consumer Reports" criticized the junk science on his fluoridation work, but the Fluoride Action Network website still praises his expertise work), Dr. Stanley Monteith (he's a long time John Birch Society member and believes a "New World Order" conspiracy is out there), Dr. Mehmet Oz (he promotes reverse osmosis filters to remove fluoride and promotes other alternative health care, plus he has alternative health care people on his TV show, like Dr. Mercola), Dr. Paul Connett (he brags about having so many dentists, but he only has 200 dentists out of the nation's 150,000 dentists on his professional statement to end fluoride, his website Fluoirde Action Netowrk is family owned and family operated, plus they quote him as being over heard to say, "In an unguarded moment with an interviewer, Connett recently stated, 'All these liberal commentators around the world immediately jump in and use the fact that the Tea Party is involved to slam us as being crazy conspiracy theorists. We might be wrong, but we’re not looney.'”), Christopher Bryson (not only does his research not meet up to "scientific scrutiny" and is of "poor quality," he also paints this horrible picture against fluoride when he said in a public interview, '“The post-war campaign to fluoridate drinking water was less a public health innovation than a public relations ploy sponsored by industrial users of fluoride including the government’s nuclear weapons program.'”), Dr. Hardy Limeback (direct quote from them: "He seems to have changed his support for fluoridation after losing a bid for the presidency of the Canadian Dental Association."), Carol Kopf (member of NYSCOF, housewife with no medical training, and a ghost writer for others in the NYSCOF).

The conclusion statements from the two dentists' "white paper":




"The anti-fluoridationists’ fake scientific controversy has resulted in reduced dental health, needless pain, suffering, and lost productivity, with substantially increased financial burdens on individuals and our health care system.  The anti-fluoridation movement employs classic propaganda methods, such as misrepresentation, fear mongering, false analogies and outright lies to further their political goals. As William Jarvis, past executive director of the National Council Against Health Fraud, has said:

"These charges seem to grow out of a mentality of distrust. Anti-fluoridation groups are led by many of the same people who oppose immunization, pasteurization, sex education, mental health programs, and other public health advances. Most are closely connected with sellers of alternatives to medically accepted products and services.
"Fluoridation is safe, effective, efficient, socially equitable, and environmentally sound public health policy for the prevention of the most common disease afflicting children and adults. It is imperative that the optimal fluoridation of community water systems continue throughout the United States and, indeed, the world."

White Paper: The Anti-Fluoridationist Threat to Public Health, April 2012
    Remember, the Florida author in the other article that brought this "white paper" to our attention, Jann Bellamy, who said to take this "white paper" with you to city council meetings if a "water war" starts so that you can "defend your community's health" with it.  We can't let this slide so that it becomes acceptable to think this way against open, honest reporting of scientific evidence that's out there, and then be labeled as a "threat."  As one of my secretaries puts it, you exterminate bugs and diseases that are a "threat" to public health, and asks if they're intending to do the same with these pesky little anti-fluoridationists.  What's your opinion on this latest development against opponents of fluoride?  Anybody know somebody who can and will go through the "white paper" point after point and write a legal, hard-core, third-party evidence type of rebuttal (that's legal-speak for evidence that holds up in court, which their "white paper" is more about slander and libel and should be laughed out of any city council meeting if they are reality-based), and that they can have the same weight of authority behind their rebuttal as the two dentists have in their "white paper."





Being Anti-Fluoride is Now a Threat to Public Health??

Anti-fluoridation argument has no teeth
By Jann Bellamy
05/16/12

A water war has been raging in Pinellas County. The opening volley was fired by the Pinellas County Commission, which voted to end fluoridation of the public water supply.

As the Tampa Bay Times recently opined, four Pinellas County Commissioners, dubbed the “Fluoride Four,” “blindly accepted misinformation about fluoride and misguided rhetoric about small government from the tea party crowd.”

But six cities in the county, including St. Petersburg, are fighting back for public health by either retaining their own fluoridated water systems or adding fluoride to county-supplied water.

Wading into the fray are two dentists, one from Tallahassee, who last month authored a white paper titled The Anti-Fluoridationist Threat to Public Health. The paper is issued under the auspices of the Institute for Science in Medicine and can be accessed through the Institute’s website. (Disclosure: I am a Fellow of the Institute, a non-profit “think tank” devoted to science-based medicine and public health, and serve on its Board of Directors.)

The authors are John Dodes, DDS, a New York dentist and expert on dental health fraud, and Floridian Michael Easley, DDS, MPH. Among other government, university and private sector positions in dental health, Dr. Easley is a former official in the Florida Department of Health Public Health Dental Program.

Like other reports from organizations such as the American Dental Association, the National Institutes of Health, and the Pew Center on the States, this paper summarizes the overwhelming evidence in favor of community water fluoridation. For example, the paper notes that for every dollar spent, CWF saves an average of $38 to $80 per year in dental treatment costs. And CWF lowers the rate of tooth decay in children by 20 percent to 40 percent over and above the effect of toothpaste and other fluoride sources.

While such facts are important weapons in the fight against ignorance, they are too often met with “facts” from the anti-fluoridation crowd. Without considerable time and effort, it is hard to defend against their misinformation campaign.

And there lies the utility of Dr. Dodes’s and Dr. Easley’s white paper -- it calmly and succinctly deconstructs the arguments of anti-fluoridationists, the same “facts” used by the “Fluoride Four” in depriving Pinellas County residents of what the CDC named one of the ten greatest public health achievements of the 20th century.

For example, a favorite scare tactic of fluoride opponents is to exaggerate a condition called dental fluorosis, a mild cosmetic condition, usually detectable only by a dentist, which has no effect on the health or function of the teeth. Opponents also like to point out that in India, excessive fluoride has caused a disfiguring condition called skeletal fluorosis, a condition virtually non-existent in the U.S.

What they fail to tell you is that the cause of this condition is not CWF, but rather fluoride in the Indian water supply, some of it caused by pollution, which is four to 15 times higher than the level used to fluoridate the public water supply in the U.S.

Another favorite is the claim that most European governments have rejected fluoridation. In fact, as Drs. Dodes and Easley point out, Great Britain, Ireland, Spain and other European countries do fluoridate. Others do not, but rely on alternate sources, such as naturally occurring fluoride (so there is no need to supplement) as well as fluoridated salt and milk.

Other tactics include using outdated quotes from medical authorities, failure to disclose the institution of alternate methods of fluoride delivery where governments have ceased CWF (such as in Cuba), and lifting quotes from public health organizations out of context, thereby making it seem as if the organization opposes fluoridation when actually it does not.

Opponents of fluoridation, like vaccination opponents, are a tiny but very vocal minority with an outsized effect on public health. Their success is dependent upon a campaign of misinformation couched in the language of science. Unearthing their half-truths and misrepresentations requires time and expertise few public officials or average citizens possess. Fortunately, Dr. Dodes and Dr. Easley have done the heavy lifting for us.

If fluoridation opponents start a water war in your community, be prepared to defend your community’s health with a copy of The Anti-Fluoridationist Threat to Public Health.
http://www.scienceinmedicine.org/policy/papers/AntiFluoridationist.pdf